Biologic response modifiers act by binding TNF a dominant cytokine that plays
a prominent role in inflammation which is responsible for the pain and swelling seen in RA patients.After a connection between
TNF and joint erosion was established by research,scientists were able to engineer a TNF antibody (Remicade) that destroys
TNF,and in the case of Enbrel (protein) "sops up" excessive TNF.
Biotechnology is the industry that has found ways to create new drugs from
molecules that naturally exist in the human body. It is a type of technology that has allowed researchers to identify
how disease states normally occur,and how they can actually devise drugs to treat disease states that was not possible
in the past.
Biologic drugs are the genes, proteins, or cells that are found to be involved in disease environments that can
be controlled, to use in attacking and help preventing the disease.
A great many of these products are produced in the body and re- produced in minute amounts-to make them in sufficient
amounts so that they can be used for clinically testing-they have to use what is called recombient genetic engineering.
What scientists do with that content,is to isolate the gene that is providing the information to the cells by which these
complex molecules are formed. That gene is tailored,and divided in a smaller organism-the machinery by which genes are translated
into complex molecules are known as proteins is common to all organism in the planet.
Scientists harness that knowledge to put the gene that encodes TNF receptor-into a cell or another organism to control
to a much greater extent for the production of these biologics. A conventional drug like methotrexate,may be composed
of 20 carbon atoms and a bio- technology drug is composed of thousands of carbon atoms that are put together to create
these molecular complexities.
The major reason that cytokines (TNF & IL-1)
are the appropiate targets for biologic therapy is that they're found in excess amounts in people with rheumatoid arthritis.
What happens,is they get painful but very swollen joints. And their joints,when felt,they feel like bread-dough:they're squishy.
That squishiness or "bread-dough" feeling is actually the joint lining,which normally,in people without RA,a microscope is
required to see,and normally can't be felt. In RA patients,it becomes very thick,and this thick joint lining then starts causing
the pain and associated inflammation,and eats away at the bone and cartilage. Rheumatologists are trained at medical school
to feel this manisfestation.
When this thick synovium or joint lining is analyzed,it's enriched with all of those little proteins or cytokines,and
that's why targetting is important .Those cytokines are not seen in patients with many other arthritic diseases,including
Osteoarthritis.
The two main cytokines,or proteins,or "e-mails" of the immune system are (tumour necrosis factor) and IL-1 (interleukin-1)
Both of these have been demonstrated to be increased,in people with RA. That is why it was chosen as one of the proteins to
target through bio-technology and the use of genetic engineering.
One of the advantages of biologic drugs (BRMs)is they act specifically to neutralize
cytokine proteins,and unlike traditional DMARDs,they are not processed by the organs of the human body,(stomach) resulting
in potentially less side effects.
Cytokines are a group of proteins that regulate the immune system's activity. In general cytokines can either stimulate
or stifle the immune response. Two important cytokines,Tumour Necrosis Factor (TNF)-alpha and Interleukin-1 (IL-1),help orchestrate
the active phases of RA. Note,these cytokines are found in the joints of all RA patients. Research aimed at inhibiting the
activity of these cytokines has resulted in a number of new drugs for RA treatment.
TNF-alpha plays a central role in initiating events that lead to inflammation and
destruction of joints. It stimulates the production of molecules necessary to attract white blood cells to joint spaces. It
also stimulates the release of other enzymes with the ability to breakdown components of the joint (like collagen,cartilage,and
bone). Inhibiting the ability of TNF-alpha to initiate these events could dampen the destructive processes in RA. Many TNF-alpha
inhibitors are in development. Recently,the FDA approved two TNF-alpha inhibitors. These inhibitors block TNF activity by
blocking production of TNF or by preventing TNF from binding to its receptor.
Interleukin-1 (IL-1),activates several inflammatory cells and stimulates those cells
to release other pro-inflammatory substances. Several IL-1 inhibitors designed to block Il-1's pro-inflammatory effects have
shown promise in animal studies. Recently,the FDA aprroved Kineret. These inhibitors block IL-1 activity by one of three main
mechanisms: by preventing Il-1 from binding to its receptor,by blocking production of IL-1 or by blocking intracellular signaling
once IL-1 has bound to its receptor. (Scientists say inflammatory cells "talk-to-each-other",or signal-each-other in the inflammatory
orchestration.)
Etanercept is a synthetic protein that essentially acts as a decoy for the
TNF circulating in the blood stream. It binds with TNF molecules,thereby preventing them from penetrating the cells to continue
the process of inflammation. By capturing TNF in this way,etanercept supplements the body's naturally occurring TNF regulators
so that they are not so overwhelmed.
Etanercept is used in people who have active rheumatoid arthritis and have not significantly improved after treatment
with DMARDs. The rheumatoligist may also recommend that it to be used before other therapies are tried. Enbrel also appears
to boost the effectiveness of traditional DMARD therapy. Adding Enbrel to standard methotrexate therapy,e.g.,resulted in a
75% improvement in the number of tender joints--almost double that provided to people taking MTX alone.
The drug works quickly,in as little as two weeks,although it may take up to three months to feel the full effects Studies
that have being ongoing for the last 5 years show that the drug continues to work as long as the medication is taken,and X-rays
show that it slows damage to the joint.
In adults, etanercept is taken twice per week in 25-milligram (mg) injections underneath
the skin in the thigh, abdomen or upper arm. You can inject the drug yourself, or have the injections given by a partner or
caregiver. The drug must be kept refrigerated because it is a natural protein that can break down at room temperature
Another biological agent,Infliximab (Remicade) also targets TNF but in a different
way from Enbrel Rather then absorbing excessive TNF,infliximab uses a monoclonal antibody,that hunts down TNF and neutralizes
it so that it has no effect. The antibody is produced in mouse,humanized and used in humans.
Infliximab is administered intravenously. The exact dose is
based on your weight. A health professional experienced in giving infusions administers the drug directly into your vein.
The infusion process, which takes about two hours, can be done at a infusion center. After a initial three infusions,over
the course of six week--then a maintenance dose received every other month. In the first year the patient should expect about
eight infusions;therafter,about six doses per year. This medication is given in conjunction with methotrexate.
Anakinra is taken on a daily basis in 100-mg injections underneath
the skin. You can inject the drug yourself, or have the injections given by a partner or caregiver. Anakinra should not be
used in combination with TNF inhibitors. Kineret is a IL-1 inhibitor. It may be more suitable to use this drug with another
DMARD.
BRM's affect the immune system, etanercept, infliximab and anakinra
have the potential to make patients vulnerable to infections. Safeguards, such as not beginning therapy during an infection
or modifying the dose should an infection develop, have made the risk of more serious infection with these drugs small. However,
serious infections have been associated with these BRMs. If
you develop symptoms of infection while using etanercept, infliximab or anakinra, call you doctor so you can receive proper
evaluation and treatment.
People taking them should not receive live vaccinations such as oral polio, chickenpox or
the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine. Discuss these risks with your doctor
to determine if the benefits of taking a BRM outweigh the potential side effects and risks.Patients
should not take BRMs if they have an active, serious infection. People who are getting adequate relief from other treatments
probably will not need to take a BRM.
Due to the groundbreaking research and development required to produce BRMs, these drugs
cost more than some other medications. Check with your insurance provider to find out if these medications are covered.
Currently,BRMs are not for everyone.
A New DMARD: Leflunomide (ARAVA)
Leflunomide,marked under the brand name Arava,is a type of immunosuppressant that belongs to the family
of DMARDs. Although its exact action in rhematoid arthritis is unclear (the manufacturer has a web site explanation one the
drug),this new medication appears to work by inhibiting immune cells that are rapidly dividing which promote inflammation
in joints.
In early clinical trials leflunomide worked as well as the more standard DMARDs, methotrexate and sulfasalazine.
As such,it may provide another option for RA patients This medication alleviates pain and swelling,and reduces the total number
of tender joints in some patients. Studies have shown that it slows the progression of the disease. Arava must be prescribed
It may take at least one month and up to three months for results. Arava does not work for all patients like any other medication.
The most common side effects are abdominal pain,diarrhea,rash, and hair loss(but these end when medication
is stopped. While taking this drug the blood will be tested regularily to test for drug toxicity. There is a 3 day loading
dose of 100 mg/daily and thereafter a daily dose of 10 mg or 25 mg/daily depending upon patient.
Leflunomide can cause birth defects. It also remains in the body long after the last pill was taken
(up to 2 years). If a patient wants to become pregnant speak to the physician. He/she can best advise how to discontinue the
drug and eliminate it from the body.
The Prosoba Column: A Blood-filtering Device ( It is not a BRM )
If you have moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis and have not benifited from treatment with one or
more DMARDs,another option may be the Prosoba column,a blood filterig device approved by the FDA in 3/99.
The Prosorba column function much like a kidney dialysis machine. The patient is connected to the machine,the
blood is withdrawn through a tube,filtered through the column,removing certain substances involved in rheumatoid arthritis,and
then returned to the bloodstream.
The procedure takes about 2 hours and is usually done once a week for 12 weeks. It can be done in a
out-patient basis. Clinical studies showed that it generally took all 12 treatments before people noticed any benifit.
Side effects most commonly reported are chills,mild fever,nausea,and joint pain (similar to that of
flu) for a day or two,after treatment. Other side effects include headache,anemia,sore throat,abdominal pain,rash,and dizziness.
There are many new questions to be addressed in use and treatment of biologics in RA: 1)How much better is combination
therapy based on the data we have? 2)How much better is combination than monotherapy? 3)Are you thinking about using these
drugs as monotherapy? 4)Do we want combinations with traditional DMARDS? 5) Do we reach for a step up or step down ? Most
of the research data suggests a affirmative answer.
Nearly every combination trial we have "HARD DATA " on is a biologic plus methotrexate trial, which brings
the question of whether that's the optimal combination, or whether we're going to move on and try more combinations of biologics.
The cost of a single biologic prohibits it's use widely.
Some trials have been tried and it appears to work in certain very small trials, (we need larger trials ),but with
Kineret (IL-1),more data suggests not to use it with biologics in combination. Toxicity seems to be the major problem.
Every trial we've looked at has evaluated patients on methotrexate. We add a biologic. Seventy-five percent to 80%
of our patients have relentless disease, and at this point in time, we do not know who's going to go on to have the worst
disease except for some easy predictors -- nodules at presentation, erosions at presentation, more than 20 joints. (Polyarthritis
is defined as arthritis in 4 or more joints)
Let's consider patients with polyarticular disease that's seropositive with or without nodule, the people you think
have definite RA. Should we be treating them all with biologics, methotrexate, and corticosteroids,or are we going to continue
to gradually add medications.
How do you make a decision now about who gets what drug? Who do you put on infliximab or enbrel? The usual answer
is people who can convince the "special access board" in Ontario Canada.
More questions to be considered is that a lot of important informative data is presented by the drug manufacturers
themselves. Clinical trials are sponsored by the manufacturers. They are in business to make much profit as possible.
Is too much hype,patient selection,or over-promotion of the product itself,entering into the equation,even thought
the product itself is basically sound and effective ? Are we getting the answers we really require ?
The current practise is those who do not respond to,or cannot tolerate conventional drugs is put on biologics. There
are also patients who do not respond to biologics.
It has to do not with efficacy or what you know about the drugs. It's about who's going to pay and how easy it is
for them to get the drug. It shouldn't be based just on your insurance type, but are there characteristics of disease where
one patient is going to respond better than another?
Preexisting liver disease with methotrexate, if on leflunomide, limit their use. What are the issues with one biologic?
An example is pregnancy where we don't know. Also, renal failure where we don't know. Think of different situations, different
conditions, where we may want data.
Some of that data are already available and we need to mine it so we can make some decisions using evidence-based
medicine,not rely on intelligent guessing,which doctors often use successfully,in current practise.
The use of biologics in RA has already revolutionized treatment options, and further studies will be necessary to
clarify which patients with RA should actually,receive which drug and when. The future of these drugs looks exciting and promising,except
for the cost factor.
But if they are really effective (short term)as Immunex (sold out to SP)paints the picture and is efficacious as
reported by them. The long term cost of treating RA patients may be more cost effective in the long run when cost factor
involved in the long -term treatment by conventional therapy is compared to biologic therapy short term. It doesn't take a
genius to figure that out.
Perhaps we have to wait until we find the real cause and cure of rheumatoid arthritis for all the answers.
There is a study of anakinra plus etanercept. Schiff et al studied 58 patients with RA in a safety trial. This was a tolerability
trial and 21 patients discontinued the drug. They reported something and were taken off. Twenty-eight of the 58 had infections.
There were 48 infections, but only 4 patients had serious infections. Maybe that's a lot, but they weren't opportunistic infections
or TB. In fact, they were serious infections because it was a safety trial. If they reported something, they were thrown in
the hospital. What they had was cellulitis and community-acquired pneumonia. They responded very nicely to typical treatment.
But this is part of what the FDA evaluated when considering anakinra safety. Therefore, there is a rider in the package
insert about not using combinations of biologics, and it's based on this safety trial. It suggests combinations of biologics
may be too toxic, but the science community says a few other trials are necessary.
|